 |
ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS
To protect scheme members' interests, the MPFA adopts various practicable means to enforce the law against employers who fail to make MPF contributions for their employees or who do not enrol their
employees in MPF schemes. In accordance with the MPF legislation, a surcharge calculated at 5% of the default contribution amount is imposed on employers who default in making MPF contributions for their employees. The surcharges received are credited into the employees' MPF accounts. During the year,
328 400 such payment notices were issued.
Civil claims are an effective means to recover contributions and surcharges in arrears. Since 2004, an increasing number of claims have been filed with the District and High Courts. In 2005-06, the MPFA filed 86 claims at District Court and two claims at High Court on behalf of 1 513 employees in total. During the year, there were also 909 cases, involving 1 598 employees, submitted to the Small Claims Tribunal. District Court and High Court claims were found to be more cost-effective, benefiting more employees. In addition, the MPFA made 369 applications (on behalf of 7 370 employees) to liquidators in respect of default contribution cases.
When the MPFA investigates suspected default contribution cases, some employers would pay the contributions in arrears after persuasion and counselling by the MPFA's inspectors. Where the default situation continues, and if sufficient evidence and witnesses are available, the MPFA would, after obtaining legal advice, refer the cases to the Department of Justice and the Police for criminal prosecution. During the year, the MPFA completed investigation into 9 218 complaint cases and applied for 924 summonses. Among the 126 employers (involving 670 summonses) who had taken plea by 31 March 2006, 107 (involving 584 summonses) pleaded guilty or were convicted. The total amount of fines imposed was $1,514,200. Among the summonses issued, 120 were laid against 22 directors/managers of limited companies. Thirteen of these directors/managers were convicted and fined $7,000 to $47,000 each. One case was withdrawn while the rest were pending court judgement.
The MPFA also applies for garnishee orders1 to enforce court orders where the employers do not pay the judgement debt before the date set. A total of 126 garnishee orders were applied during the year, successfully recovering $577,000 of outstanding MPF contributions and surcharges.
The MPFA is empowered under the MPF legislation to impose financial penalties on defaulting employers. During the year 2005-06, financial penalties of $5,000 for each case were imposed on 13 employers with substantiated defaulting offences. They included repeated defaulters who owed substantial amounts of outstanding default contributions but had no complainants, and cases where there was prima facie evidence to proceed with prosecution but there was no willing witness. All of them admitted the default and paid the penalties.
Proactive
Measures
In addition to carrying out investigations
in response to complaints, the MPFA proactively inspects
business establishments to check on non-enrolment and defaults
in contribution. The number of proactive inspections conducted
in 2005-06 was 2 552. Major targets of these inspections
included construction sites, catering establishments and
retail outlets. Joint inspections were held with the Labour
Department at the work places of government contractors
providing cleansing, pest control and security services.
In 2005-06, an additional team was set up
under the Special Task Force, established since 2004, to
conduct investigation of default contribution cases reported
by trustees and which were not initiated by complainants.
The Special Task Force completed investigation of about
820 employers during the year, and civil claims were pursued
in substantiated cases.
During the year, the MPFA recovered $80.2
million of default MPF contributions at various levels
of court, or by persuasion and counselling of employers
concerned. Statistics on enforcement actions are set out
in Part E on page 117 of the Statistics section. |
 |